Short answer

Atherton and Woodside both offer detached homes with substantial grounds, but the land can work differently. In Atherton, a tour often starts with the house, garden and distance from neighboring homes. Woodside adds wooded slopes, open acreage and, on some properties, equestrian facilities. It also has a small village center. Atherton’s sale median was higher in the shared reporting window. Tour both if you’re still deciding how much land you’d actually use.

Market data

Market numbers

Redfin city data, all residential property types, three months ending September 2026.

Atherton

Median sale price

$11,994,288

Median sale price per square foot

$2,401.03

Median days on market

19 days

Closed sales

21

Woodside

Median sale price

$4,622,799

Median sale price per square foot

$1,415.46

Median days on market

29 days

Closed sales

18

Both towns had relatively few closings. A handful of expensive properties can move either median.

Compare the primary houses separately from any barn, guest quarters or grounds. Then look at how similar properties were priced and how long they took to sell.

Side by side

Factor Atherton Woodside
Land pattern Estate lots and smaller pockets Village lots, acreage and wooded slopes
Lot rules One acre for new R-1A subdivisions Check the district and parcel
Housing Older detached houses and new estates Cottages, ranches and custom homes
Shopping No commercial downtown Small village center
Caltrain No in-town stop No in-town stop
Property tax base 1% plus applicable charges 1% plus applicable charges
Parcel records Check access and parcel lines Check access and parcel lines

Lot and tax rules reviewed as of November 2026. The subdivision minimum describes a zoning rule. Check existing parcel dimensions and ask planning what can be changed, especially if the house or driveway already occupies the most practical part of the lot.

Drive into both properties and take the route you’d use with groceries or visitors. If a Woodside listing mentions a trail, check exactly where you would join it and confirm the access rights before putting a value on it.

Living there

01

Living in Atherton

Atherton Historic Town Hall

In Lindenwood, the older estate gates and long stretches of hedge give you an early sense of the lot pattern. Much of what you’ll use at home can sit behind the front elevation, so look at how the garden meets the house. A smaller, older house can still have a well-placed terrace and space around it. A larger build on similar land may put the outdoor area somewhere you’d use less often.

Lloyden Park gives you a more compact version of Atherton, with sidewalks and smaller properties. It’s a useful stop if you’re wondering how much of an estate you really want to maintain. West of Alameda has older houses and custom builds, and the approach from the street can vary from one property to the next. Walk the driveway before you leave.

Atherton has no commercial downtown. Holbrook-Palmer Park is an in-town outing, and for groceries or dinner you can test the drive from the house to the shopping area you’d actually use.

02

Living in Woodside

Redwood forest and a road in Woodside

Around central Woodside, you can stop at Roberts Market and see how the village works before looking at properties farther out. The settings change quickly. Some houses sit beside open ground with room for a barn or paddock, while others sit in trees with most of their outdoor living on a deck or terrace. Neither the acreage nor the listing map tells you which setup you’ll use more.

Woodside Hills offers another version of town, with houses on rising ground and some lots that open toward the Bay. On a tour there, pay attention to the driveway and the steps from parking to the main floor. In a wooded setting, look at how much daylight reaches the rooms and yard you’d use most.

The town maintains trail information, and Huddart Park gives you another way to spend time outdoors. If you’re drawn to an address because of trails, try the actual approach from the house. Access from one property can be very different from access from the next.

School districts

Assignment depends on the property address. Enter the full street address in the SMCOE School District Locator and confirm with the district.

FAQ

Can I keep horses on a Woodside property?

Check the parcel with town planning before assuming a barn, paddock or advertised acreage is enough. Ask which uses are allowed, what approvals exist for the structures and where a trailer could turn. If riding out matters, confirm the route from the property to the trail. Give the existing setup a separate inspection.

Should I expect a septic system?

Ask the seller which sewer or septic system serves the house and request the records. If there’s septic, get the layout and service history and ask a specialist what future replacement would involve. If an addition is part of your plan, check how it would interact with that system before committing to a design.

What should I verify on a property with a guesthouse?

Ask to see the approved plans and final permit records. Check whether the file describes it as a dwelling, guest quarters or another kind of structure. If you need a separate residence or rental, confirm the allowed use with the town. The kitchen you see during a showing does not settle the question.

How should I budget for maintaining wooded land?

Get records or quotes for tree work, drainage, road upkeep and any shared maintenance. Ask what happened after recent storms and who paid for repairs. Walk beyond the landscaped area so you know where the work would be. An attractive grove and a long private driveway can have very different ongoing costs.

What should I check if the driveway is shared?

Review the recorded easement and any written maintenance agreement. Ask who can use the road, how costs are split and whether the documents cover guests, deliveries or construction vehicles. Walk the actual route and check where vehicles pass or turn. If a gate is involved, confirm who controls it and how access works.

Related comparisons

Atherton vs Menlo ParkAtherton vs Hillsborough

Talk through your options

Send me the properties you’re comparing and I’ll help you identify what to check about the land, access and outbuildings.

Talk through your options
All cities and neighborhoods